I have challenged the good guys over at War Eagle Extra to put this thing together.

I would love to see someone put together a list of all 4 and 5 star athletes from the past 5 or 6 years and tell us where they are now. All this talk about coaching them up versus more 5 stars equal success could finally be put to rest. I would just like to see how many of these guys had great college careers and how many went on to play pro ball.

I have also suggested that someone break down, in detail, how these stars are handed out. Who is actually doing the grading and how are they qualified? Just what do they grade? Is it done through game film or in person?

Sure we all want our team to pull in the stud guys, but I have never gotten to excited about the whole star ranking. I am not a pro sports blogger by no means, but I see teams winning who are not pulling in all these studs. I would really just like an honest to goodness review of how the 5 stars fared in their career.